Designing Atomic Level Process Chemistries. The Role of Atomistic Simulation in Developing Sustainable Deposition and Etch Processes.
Michael Nolan
Head of Group Materials Modelling for Devices
Tyndall National Institute
Abstract
In modern semiconductor device fabrication, the dimensions involved means that Atomic Level Processing, exemplified by Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD), is widely used for film deposition. Further scaling and use of complex three-dimensional structures means that Thermal Atomic Layer Etch (tALE) will start to take centre stage in etching. The key chemistry takes place at surfaces which drives the self-limiting characteristics and other advantages of these atomic level processing approaches.However, there is a side to device processing that needs to be addressed and this is the heavy environmental impact and non-sustainable nature of current atomic level processing chemistries. Specific examples include: up to 99% of precursors introduced into the processing tool are simply wasted, the high process temperatures, the complex synthesis of precursors (which can add to their high cost), using fluorinated and other environmentally unfriendly chemicals, the large number of sequential deposition & etch cycles which remove material that is wasted and the potentially large number of laboratory experiments (many of which fail) that are needed to develop a new process chemistry. I will present how first principles atomistic simulations based on Density Functional Theory can be used to predict the chemistry of atomic level deposition and etch processes and how these simulations can help with enhancing the sustainability of semiconductor devices processing, setting the industry on the path to truly green and sustainable manufacturing processes. The first topic is the simulation of plasma enhanced deposition (PE-ALD) of metals, using the example of cobalt for next generation interconnects. Our simulations show the first example of an atomistic level study of the full PE-ALD cycle for Co metal. We showed that the process requires use of ammonia or mixed H2/N2 plasma, eliminating the requirement to explore different plasmas to see what works. Calculated energy barriers for key steps give guidance regarding the temperatures required for the process, eliminating the need to explore the role of temperature through multiple time and resource consuming experiments. Finally, we also show how substrate pre-treatment can reduce nucleation delay and therefore deposit the target film more rapidly.Our second example is MLD of hybrid materials, using alucone and titanicone as the prototypical examples. Using aliphatic ethylene glycol and glycerol results in less-than-ideal growth per cycle (they lie flat) and poor ambient stability. Therefore, we developed functionalized benzene rings as rigid alternatives and show that the molecules remain upright, which provides high GPC and stability. Subsequent work on titanicones with both DFT and experiment, using these aromatic precursors, confirms the enhanced stability of MLD films using aromatic molecule, which also show high growth rates. My presentation therefore demonstrates how first principles simulations are a vital part of developing greener and more sustainable atomic level processing chemistries for semiconductor device processing. Finding efficient processes through simulations can increase the usage and efficiency of film processing. Other examples where simulations can and will play a role include developing non-halogenated ALE chemistries, better design of reactors to maximise precursor use, better precursor design with higher atom economy and finding alternatives to unsustainable synthesis chemistries.
Biography
Dr. Michael Nolan is the Head of Group - Materials Modelling for Devices at Tyndall National Insitute, UCC, Ireland. Tyndall is Ireland's leading ICT and DeppTech research institute with close on 600 staff and students and is world leading in ICT, communications, photonics, device processing and materials. Dr. Nolan is also interim Cheif Scientist, Chairperson of the Science Council of the Irish Centre for High End Computing and Associate Editor of the Diamond Open Access Beilstein Journal of Nanotechnology. He is a Funded Investigator on the Science Foundation Ireland Research Centres Insight, AMBER and VistaMilk. Currently Dr. Nolan leads a team of 4 PhD students and 7 postdocs in the first principles simulation of new atomic level processing chemistries, which is carried out together with leading groups in Europe, including M. Knez, A. Devi, C. Detavernier and M. Karppinen and beyond, e.g. S. George. This encompasses atomic layer deposition, atomic layer etch and hybrid molecule layer deposition.He received his PhD in Microelectronic Engineering in 2004 from University College Cork and was a postdoc with Prof. G. Watson (Chemistry, Trinity CD 2003-05) and Dr. S. Elliott (Tyndall Institute 2005-09) and has been a tenured researcher since 2009, having been promoted to Principal Scientist in 2015 and Head of Group in 2022. Dr. Nolan has graduates 7 PhDs and supervised 7 postdocs. He has published extensively on modelling of surfaces and surface chemistry for energy, semidonductor device and medical device applications.An important aspect of the group's work is interaction with industry, either through direct funding or leveraged co-funding. Work with industry includes LAM Research (Enterprise Ireland Innovation Partnership, co-I), Stryker (Enterprise Ireland Innovation Partnership, lead-I), Intel, Applied Materials and Logitech, with other contracts subject to commercial sensitivity. Dr. Nolan has a licence agreement with UMICORE and two patents.